The Southern Fans' College Football Poll: SEC
Showing posts with label SEC. Show all posts
Showing posts with label SEC. Show all posts

Thursday, September 3, 2009

No. 1 FLORIDA GATORS



Gators try to be first to win 3 BCS titles

Here we go again.

2002 Miami. 2003 Oklahoma. 2005 USC. 2006 Ohio State.

Not only isn't there a reason to play the national title game, there's no reason to play the season. Hand over the crystal ball to Urban Meyer and the Gators. No one's going to beat Tim Tebow and all those returning starters - how many are there now? 48? Wow!

Florida's now in the realm of being called the best team of all-time, which has only been spouted out by ESPN pundits six different times this decade. Sure the Gators are going to be tough, but no Gator team has ever gone through a season unscathed (though every UF fan still remembers that 5-0-1 team in 1911).

While Florida's non-conference schedule still nothing outside the season-ender against Florida State, the Gators just need to make it through the SEC (which is now the undisputed king of college football, with five BCS champions and an undefeated league champion in the BCS's 11-year history). But this Florida class has a chance to leave it's mark as the BCS's first true dynasty; and while many schools have had successful runs, no team has left their imprint since Nebraska in the mid-90's, which also had one of the best QB's of all-time in Tommy Frazier.

And Tebow has almost wrapped up the moniker of best college QB ever. From being an impact player on the 2006 champion squad, to the first sophomore to ever win the Heisman, to the sappy post-game speech, to the cult-like status that he's acquired, Tebow has done everything

But like 1999 Tennessee, 2000 Florida State, 2001 Oklahoma, 2002 Miami, 2003 Ohio State, 2004 LSU, 2005 USC, are the Gators putting too much pressure on themselves to repeat? Anything less than an undefeated national championship season is seen as below expectations. Anything other than routing SEC foes Tennessee, Georgia and South Carolina will be seen as disappointing.

The college football world is already lining it's self up to give Florida a freebie. There's talk of whether a once beaten Gators team is more deserving to play an unbeaten USC or Texas/Oklahoma than an unbeaten ACC or Big East champion. Florida doesn't have to worry about that right now; Urban and Co. can justbask in the glory of entering the season as the Southern Fans' No. 1 team.

CFN 2009 Preview | ESPN Florida Page | CBS Florida Page

Part of a two-week long look into the 2009 Preseason Southern Fans' College Football Poll.

Tuesday, September 1, 2009

NO. 6 ALABAMA CRIMSON TIDE



Saban has Tide gunning for more than SEC West title

For Alabama, 2008 was indeed an aberration. That team played over it's head throughout the season, made clutch plays when required, caught teams at the right times and had a senior, seasoned quarterback to lead the way. Last season Bama had its fans bewildered and unbelievably anticipating a 13th National Title that no one in August would've thought was possible. That won't be the case in 2009.

Yes, for the Crimson Tide, 2008 won't be the catalyst for a great 2009. Alabama was, is and will rock during the 2009 season, and what happened in 2008 won't have made any difference. The Tide is legitimately a top six team entering this season, and they will be up and ready to bring it each week.

All 2008 did was show that Nick Saban's no-nonsense approach and general asshole reputation would work and even fans at a school as obsessed as Alabama would follow suit. The only area where 2008 might have played a role is the loss to Utah, which left the Tide hungry while also seeming to take the bulls-eye off the Tide (and surprisingly, thanks to the Ole Miss win over Texas Tech, putting it on the Rebels).

Now people will be gunning for Alabama, but that's the pressure that the Tide and its fans crave. They, like Florida, LSU, USC, Texas and Ohio State, want everyone's best shot. Saban has to replace stars in the offensive and defensive backfield, and yet will return a more capable team.

Outside of the showdown against Virginia Tech in Atlanta, where Bama will go to 2-0 in Chick-fil-a Kickoffs, the Tide has no one of note out-of-conference. The roughest road game will be at Ole Miss in early October, when the Rebels will probably have lost at least two games. The biggest games are at home (Tennessee, USC and LSU). And the Iron Bowl in Auburn will only be relevant if the Tigers aren't completely decimated by injury.

No, in Tuscaloosa, 2008 wasn't need for a successful 2009 campaign. That was going to happen all along.

CFN 2009 Preview | ESPN Alabama Page | CBS Alabama Page

Part of a two-week long look into the 2009 Preseason Southern Fans' College Football Poll. New posts released each day, culminating with the No. 1 team on September 2.

Monday, August 31, 2009

No. 8 LSU Tigers



LSU fans expect (another) big season from Miles

In what is always a fun debate, try to name the currently-employed coach that has won a national championship but is on a hot-seat.

While this is always relative, the answer is a little more difficult to come up with then in year's past. Just a few seasons ago, the answer would've been Lloyd Carr, who won a pre-BCS AP National Title in 1997 (splitting it with Nebraska). Prior to that, Larry Coker would have topped the list, after he won a national title in his debut season at Miami. Both of these coaches have been run out though, leaving the question more difficult.

And national titles generally buy a coach a good bit of time to work through rough patches; further, some coaches have become such iconic figures for their universities (e.g. Florida State's Bobby Bowden and Penn State's Joe Paterno), that they seem to be immune from even the mention. However, one sure fire way to get to the top of the list is to win a national title with another coach's players, which leads us to...

Les Miles. Less than two seasons removed from a national title, Miles certainly isn't on a hot seat, but with the title coming with mostly Nick Saban's recruits, how much credit do Tiger fans give Miles for bringing home their second title this decade? Further, being the only BCS champion with two losses (and the first consensus champion to have two defeats since 1960) takes a little more shine off of Miles' image.

But most importantly is last season's 8-5 record, which makes fans wonder whether Miles is really a national title coach or just a Larry Coker-type babysitter who was able to lead a pre-assembled team through the season.

That worry will be answered in 2009, when Miles enters his fifth season in Baton Rouge. Now, the entire roster is made up of mostly Miles recruits and any success or failure will be on his shoulders. And Miles has toed the line of failure during his tenure - multiple times in 2007 alone, LSU narrowly escaped defeat and lost to two inferior opponents (Arkansas and Kentucky). This season, the Tigers travel in the opening week to play a much improved Washington team, have back-to-back games at Georgia and hosting Florida, travel to Alabama, and end the season with revenge games at Ole Miss and Arkansas.

While all SEC schedules are difficult, LSU needs a defining season to continue it's image as an elite of the elite program. LSU is in one of the best situation's in college football - the lone BCS program in a football rich state (even Ohio State and Penn State have Big East members Cincinnati and Pitt). But Miles is beginning to lose out on Louisiana recruits. And with Alabama and Florida becoming SEC superpower programs, Miles has to show that he can re-build that Saban-recruiting wall around the state. If he doesn't have another breakthrough season in 2009, then there's little chance of continuing to hold in the recruits, and Miles will become the debate's easy answer.

CFN 2009 Preview | ESPN LSU Preview | CBS LSU Preview

Part of a two-week long look into the 2009 Preseason Southern Fans' College Football Poll. New posts released each day, culminating with the No. 1 team on September 2.

Wednesday, August 26, 2009

No. 11 OLE MISS REBELS



Nutt, Snead have expectations high in Oxford

One of the Cinderella stories of 2008, Ole Miss starts the 2009 season just outside the top 10. But the '08 season started as inconspicuous as most others in Oxford, where Ole Miss has done a large bit of nothing over the past 45 years. The Rebels started 2-2 with narrow losses to academic heavyweights Wake Forest and Vanderbilt, but it was in late September where new coach Houston Nutt and his Rebels made the season-defining statement when they knocked off eventual champion Florida in the Swamp.

And how did Ole Miss respond to the possible program defining win? With losses at home to South Carolina and (a narrow loss) to eventual SEC West champion Alabama. At 3-4 in mid-October, Ole Miss looked to be back to regular form but then ran off six consecutive victories - including wins over Auburn, LSU and Big XII South co-champion Texas Tech - to end the season at 9-4.

And it was those wins that have gotten Ole Miss into the national conscious, and many think the Rebels have a chance to unseat Alabama and LSU to make their first SEC Championship Game ever. Playing almost no one of note out-of-conference, the Rebels' most difficult road game looks to be either South Carolina on Sept. 26 or Auburn on Halloween. Their three toughest games - Alabama, Tennessee and LSU will all have to come to Vaught-Hemingway.

But the major question - outside of whether Jevan Snead is the best QB in the SEC - is if perennial underachiever Ole Miss will be able to play at the same level as it closed last season with the large bulls-eye on its back. Nutt's team won't be able to sneak up on anyone, and if Ole Miss is actually going to make a run at a trip to Atlanta, it will have to earn it.

CFN 2009 Preview | ESPN Ole Miss Page | CBS Ole Miss Page

Part of a two-week long look into the 2009 Preseason Southern Fans' College Football Poll. New posts released each day, culminating with the No. 1 team on September 2.

Monday, August 24, 2009

No. 15 GEORGIA BULLDOGS



Expectations in Athens remain despite losing stars

One year after topping the preseason poll, Georgia enters this season at No. 15. The Bulldogs, having to replace the NFL's No. 1 overall draft pick Matthew Stafford and all-everything running back Knowshon Moreno, will open 2009 much less heralded then when they started 2008. That might be a good thing, as UGA won't have the huge target on their back like a season ago, when they finished the season with a "below expectations" 10-3.

And that pretty much sums up the attitude in Athens these days, where 10 win seasons are now looked at as pedestrian. Mark Richt has created such high expectations that many Georgia fans are waiting for that special season where everything comes together, like it has for Florida and LSU over the past decade, while those same fans worry about the juggernaut that are the Gators. Tim Tebow may be Superman to the rest of the nation (and a super human to the FOX broadcast booth), but he doesn't receive as much scorn or hatred then in Athens, Ga.

But in '09, a 10-win season might be too much to ask for; in fact, getting out of September unscathed would be a major accomplishment. The Dawgs open the season with a trip to Stillwater to play a much improved Oklahoma State team that won nine games in 2008; then they return for an always intense game against SEC East rival South Carolina; hit the road again to face an improving Arkansas squad that might actually have a quarterback to lead the Bobby Petrino aerial attack; and finally close the month at home against Arizona State. Add to those games against Tennessee, LSU, Florida and Auburn and all of a sudden counting up wins seems daunting.

Finally, the Dawgs close the season against rival and ACC heavyweight Georgia Tech, who finally hold a winning streak over their instate rival. Anyone who wants to talk about a lack of SEC scheduling may want to leave the Dawgs out of discussion, and Georgia fans may want to be appreciative of anything close to 10 wins, at least in 2009.

Final 2008 Ranking: 12

2009 CFN Preview | ESPN Georgia Page | CBS Georgia Page

Part of a two-week long look into the 2009 Preseason Southern Fans' College Football Poll. New posts released each day, culminating with the No. 1 team on September 2.

Friday, October 3, 2008

SEC Coaching Boards - Week 5

For the first time this season, UF's Urban Meyer is no longer the top coach of the SEC. Oh, and something I just noticed, four SEC coaches were once the head man at a different SEC school - Nick Saban (LSU); Tommy Tuberville (Ole Miss); Houston Nutt (Arkansas); Steve Spurrier (Florida) - and one was a coordinator at another - Bobby Petrino (Arkansas), which makes for some interesting, new rivalries; also makes it a little tough on me when typing in the school names.

1. Nick Saban, Alabama
The game in Athens was about as dominating as you get. Even though Richt wanted to say how the Dawgs won the second half, it was Alabama that truly impressed, even in the 2nd half. With UGA cutting the lead to 31-14, Bama turned back up the heat, and made the score 41-17 with four mins remaining.

2. Les Miles, LSU
Miles team took a week off but still easily beat up on Mississippi State. The Tigers get a week off before the big showdown against the Gators.

3. Urban Meyer, Florida
Meyer falls from the No. 1 ranking with the loss to Ole Miss in the Swamp. While it was only Meyer's second loss in the Swamp, there does seem to be a change going on in the SEC. No one fears Tim Tebow at quarterback, and the great Meyer-spread scheme isn't striking much fear either.

4. Mark Richt, Georgia
Richt is still ranked as the fourth best coach in the SEC, but while getting beat like a drum by the Tide in Athens, he sure didn't look like it.

5. Tommy Tuberville, Auburn
The spread is dead in Auburn, at least according to ESPN, which appears to misquote Tuberville a little. The Tiger defense might be the best they've had in 20 years, but the offense is about as inept as any team in the country.

6. Houston Nutt, Ole Miss
Nutt jumps up following his first signature win at Ole Miss. Nutt is about two plays away from having the Rebels unbeaten and in the top 10. With his ability to recruit Texas, and closer proximity to Louisiana, the Rebels have a chance to become a player in the SEC East - perhaps finally make a SEC Championship game... well, no, probably not.

7. Steve Spurrier, South Carolina
Spurrier slips not because of anything he's done, but because of the rise of Houston.

8. Bobby Johnson, Vanderbilt
Unbeaten. Highly ranked. National Television. Gameday. Everything is on the line this weekend, as all eyes are on the Commodores. A win over Auburn, which hasn't happened since 1955, would put Vandy at 5-0 and on the brink of their first bowl game in 25 years. However, with the worst offense and defense in the SEC, the Commodores are going to have to rely on their amazing turnover ratio to beat the Tigers.

9. Rich Brooks, Kentucky
Brooks' team is unbeaten this season, but no one has heard much about the Wildcats. That'll change this weekend, regardless of the outcome, as UK travels to Tuscaloosa. A win over the newly anointed No. 1 would put a lot of pressure to move Brooks up.

10. Phil Fulmer, Tennessee
Fulmer's days in Knoxville look shorter as each week goes by. While Auburn's offense might be inept, the UT offense looks almost non-existent.

Don't worry Razorbacks; the way things are going
you guys won't have Bobby for long.

11. Bobby Petrino, Arkansas
Another week, another Petrino beat-down. With this rebuilding job looking to be pretty extensive, how long until Petrino bolts for greener pastures?

12. Sylvester Croom, Mississippi State
That 2007 Coach of the Year award seems like a distant memory.

Saturday, September 27, 2008

SEC Coaching Boards - Week 4

Some movement going on in this week's coaching boards. While it won't be posted before the start of Ole Miss-Florida, their portions are already written, so everything is pre-Saturday games.

1. Urban Meyer
Florida
Meyer extends his streak over hapless Phil to four, but Meyer needs to dominate Ole Miss after the lackluster win over the Vols - pretty amazing when people are down on Florida after only beating rival UT by more than three TDs. Another poor showing against the Rebels combined with a big win in UGA/UA and the top spot might change.

2. Les Miles
LSU
So I think that Auburn is overrated, and yet move Miles up for the win over the Tigers? And over Nick f***ing Saban?!?! Well, Saban has never been able to leave Jordan-Hare with a win. Miles did it in his second try. Think that does deserve some credence - not to mention that he did it at night, which is pretty difficult, just ask Florida.

3. Nick Saban
Alabama
Saban's team completely decimated Arkansas last week, but the Tide's $4 million man fell a spot due to Miles' win in Auburn. A win over the Dawgs, and it would be almost impossible to keep Saban out of No. 1.

4. Mark Richt
Georgia
I expect UGA to win tonight; you expect UGA to win tonight; hell, even this Redneck expects UGA to win tonight, so a win won't necessarily move Richt ahead of Saban. However, a blowout win akin to the blackout stomping the Dawgs gave Auburn last season will make it difficult not to move Richt to at least number 3.

5. Tommy Tuberville
Auburn
Still scratching my head over the move to the spread, but Auburn still played LSU close. However, after seeing the Bayou Bengals in person, I am not convinced that they are a top 5 team.

6. Steve Spurrier
South Carolina
Gamecocks stuggled last week against lowly Wofford last week. Another close win this week against UAB could give enough room for Bobby Johnson to move up, and an Ole Miss upset of Florida would push Spurrier to the southern half of the SEC rankings - I think Spurrier will keep his No. 6 spot going into next week's game against the Rebels.

7. Bobby Johnson
Vanderbilt
Bobby's finally starting to get the credit that he deserves, but this ranking is probably too high. Sure he's done well with a team of mostly marginal talent, but would you really rather have Johnson walking the sideline than Nutt, Petrino or even Rich Brooks? Well, maybe more so than Rich Brooks.

8. Houston Nutt
Ole Miss
I took the Rebels and the points today; this is the type of game that Nutt makes a statement with - I mean he loses, but he doesn't get blown out. If he were to somehow win this game, Nutt would shoot up these rankings. The Rebels are on a winning streak in Gainesville though.

9. Rich Brooks
Kentucky
The Wildcats have quietly gotten off to a 3-0 start, which should be 4-0 heading into the Oct. 4 match-up with Alabama. Which makes me wonder, if Bama wins today, will Gameday head back to the state of Alabama for next week's matchup? That might seem odd, but with the way gas is disappearing in north Georgia, the Gameday guys may be lucky to get back to Atlanta.

10. Philip Fulmer
Tennessee
Fulmer rallied the fan base last week before the UF game; he wanted everyone ready to go against the hated Gators. Then he as taken to the woodshed. Think it's safe to say, Fulmer really needs the win today over Auburn. Fans are getting restless.

11. Bobby Petrino
Arkansas
Petrino is the X's and O's guy; the offensive genius that made Louisville explosive, and was ready to take Mike Vick to the Super Bowl. So how is it that his Arkansas team, one that was always a factor in the SEC West, couldn't contain Alabama? Oh, I guess that's somebody else's job; Petrino's the offensive genius - well then, nice 14 points you scored, and 14 points your QB handed to the Tide defense. Enjoy that Texas-sized beat-down today.

12. Sly Croom
Mississippi State
Croom says not to mark off his Dogs, even with the lousy 1-3 start. With MSU headed to Baton Rouge today, I have no problem marking Croom and Family as 1-4 and listing him at the bottom of the SEC - which isn't that bad - it'd make him in the top half of the Big East.

Friday, September 19, 2008

SEC Coaching Boards - Week 3

1 Urban Meyer
With this season and this team, Meyer has to beat Fulmer to keep this top spot. While he's been good against the Vols, this seems to be the type of game Meyer blows (see: Auburn over the past few years). A big win cements him at No. 1... Well, at least until the Saban-Richt showdown next week.

2 Nick Saban
After the close win over Tulane, Saban has his team on track against Western Kentucky. The future 120th team in D1-A gave up 500+ yards to the Tide. Now Saban has to get his team geared up for the 119th best team in D1-A before the showdown in Athens next weekend.

3 Les Miles
LSU was finaly able to get on a field, and they showed no signs of a hurricane hangover (I've had quite a few of those, and they can be quite a pain... Thanks Patty O). Miles has a big showdown this weekend in Auburn, where LSU hasn't one since 1998.

4 Mark Richt
Richt won't drop any in my book for the close win. As he said, that game is a bloodbath. If UGA would get the Cocks at year's end, it wouldn't be close, but they always take USC's best shots. Richt will be able to show how great he is as a coach with Arizona St, Bama and the big rivalry game against Tennessee coming up in the next few weeks.

5 Tommy Tuberville
So this spread idea... Perhaps not such a good move. While a change was definitely needed (the Gorgeous Borges Gulf Coast attack had become stale), maybe Auburn shouldn't have switched to a spread without getting a few receivers to stretch the defense. A win over LSU though would quiet the Tiger fan base, that is getting pretty restless.

6 Steve Spurrier
I can't drop Spurrier even with the loss to UGA. I still scratch my head how he hasn't been able to change the losing mentality in Columbia. Seriously, if coaching giants Lou Holtz and Spurrier can't make the Gamecocks formidable in the West, is it time to think about trading S.Carolina to the ACC for GaTech? It'd help the ACC in basketball.

7 Houston Nutt
Nutt's got a big game against Vanderbilt this weekend. A win over the Commodores, while it doesn't appear to be much, would get the Rebels heading in the right direction. I really do think this team can make some noise in the SEC West... But then in our 20-person pick'em pool, I'm barely beating a guy who takes all favorites each week (It's like I'm edging the Pick'em Chicken).

8 Phil Fulmer
While the Auburn offense is painful to watch, UT's move to the spread hasn't appeared to be much better. Everything seems to be a struggle, and last week's game was not as smooth as the final score indicated, and it was against a poor UAB team. Fulmer desperately needs the win this weekend, especially after the goof loss to UCLA, which looks horrible now.

9 Rich Brooks
Hmm... Did Kentucky play last weekend? Doesn't really matter. Brooks isn't moving any farther up and it's tough to push him down. His win over Louisville looked good after the Wed night Cardinal beat down of Kansas State.

10 Bobby Petrino
Who would've thought that the Hogs would be unbeaten heading into the Bama game? Bobby's gotta be thankful that the UT game was cancelled so his team was able to rest enough to have a shot at the Tide... Actually, I think he'd be more thankful if there was a hurricane headed for Tuscaloosa... Forecast says nope Bobby. Hope you're ready for that first L.

11 Sly Croom
While the Auburn defense is obviously one of the best in the league, the Croom offense has become a joke. Was Croom on record saying he wished he had the Tiger O... He'd love to be able to get 3 points in a SEC Game. Croom keeps this spot based off last year's SEC Coach of the Year award, but unless something happens quickly, it looks as if Johnson will be edging past him.

12 Bobby Johnson
I'm now only keeping Johnson below Croom to irk our Vandy pollster... Actually, Croom is still getting a little respect for the season last year, but a win in Oxford will shoot Johnson up the rankings (and more importantly, hit my pocketbook for $20, which will go to the aforementioned Commodore).

Saturday, September 13, 2008

SEC Coaching Board - Week 2

1 Meyer
Florida
Florida beat up on their in-state rival, but need to get some cheap scores in the fourth quarter to make the score look better. UF dominated the game on defense, but the offense still revolves around Tebow and Harvin. If Meyer can't find a way to open up the offense, then the Gators won't have a shot at the SEC, much less the national title.

2 Saban
Alabama
Saban didn't allow for a letdown game after the huge win over Clemson, but the Bama offense was horrible against lowly Tulane. The Tide D and special teams were able to win. I didn't expect Saban to allow for this sluggish home opener, but the Tide schedule does allow for some sleepwalking, at least until the SEC schedule kicks in. Saban will have his team unbeaten and ready to play against Georgia in two weeks.

3 Miles
LSU
LSU didn't play this weekend, as the Tigers had to postpone yet another game due to a hurricane. There is talk that this up-coming weekend's game may be postponed as well, and even if it's not, this just figures to be one more distraction for Miles' team before the showdown with Auburn in two weeks.

4 Richt
Georgia
Richt's team dominated last season's MAC champs, and the game was never in doubt. CMU is a pretty good team offensively, and the Dawgs held them to 17 points. Georgia's horrible slate begins with S.C. on Saturday (which is going to be a tougher game than people will be giving it credit for). Richt will have this team unbeaten for the late Sept. match-up against 'Bama.

5 Tuberville
Auburn The move to the spread started to show potential, but it was the Auburn defense that remains the staple. Obviously Tuberville can't make the running backs hold on to the ball, and Tubs is known for pulling backs who tend to fumble. The Tigers have plenty of running backs to take up the slack. Auburn will avenge that 2007 loss to MSU on Saturday, and be unbeaten with Miles coming to town on Sept. 20.

6 Spurrier
S.Carolina
I debated on dropping Spurrier below Nutt (and had the Rebels held on for the win at Wake, I would have), but I couldn't justify moving Nutt up two spots with a loss, no matter how meaningful it was. So Spurrier is barely hanging on to the No. 6 spot. The Cocks are down 0-1 in conference play, and still have Georgia, Florida, Tennessee, Kentucky, and LSU to play. The SEC championship game is obviously moot at this point, but a 7-5 season and a bowl game are still attainable. That means a win over at least one of the above teams (and Clemson). This season will test Spurrier's resolve.

7 Nutt
Ole Miss
Nutt moves up after the loss, and while I hate the moral victory, the two-point loss on Saturday at Wake would not have happened under Oregeron. Nutt has the team believing it can win, and the Rebels almost pulled out one of the biggest upsets of the season. The Rebels may not be a match in the SEC, but I still think there's a shot of them making it into the top 3 of the West.

8 Fulmer
Tennessee
Fulmer falls and the Vols didn't even play. I just had more time to think about that horrendous first half at the Rose Bowl. He was totally out-coached.

9 Brooks
Kentucky
As long as the Cats don't pull a Maryland (and quite fankly, what state school sucks as bad as Maryland? ... Oh wait, Virginia), they should be unbeaten going into the Bama game. Notice that Brooks isn't sending him to the fifth smallest stadium in Tennessee.

10 Petrino
Arkansas
Arkansas is awful. I was expecting them to be competitive, but they have narrowly escaped Western Illinois and LaMonroe. The Hogs may not win an SEC game this season.

11 Croom
Miss State
Croom's team got back in the win column, and have Auburn up on Saturday. A second win over the Tigers would make that LaTech debacle a distant memory, and set MSU for another run at a bowl game, and would send Croom way up in these rankings. That win won't happen, and Croom is going to begin to feel the heat of the bottom of the SEC.

12 Johnson
Vanderbilt
What a win by Bobby J, but I still am not about to move him up. I want to see what his team does against the rest of their SEC slate. Beating up USC this season doesn't seem like it's going to be that much to write home about. (Of course, I guess if you're a Vandy fan, every win is something to write home about.)

Saturday, September 6, 2008

SEC Coaching Boards - Week 1


For more information on the coaching boards, click here.

1 Urban Meyer
Florida W
It wasn't a great win on Saturday; things appeared shaky in the first half, but UF had little trouble with a team named Hawaii with no where near the talent Hawaii had last year. I expect Meyer to lead his team to a 21-point victory over Miami this weekend.

2Nick Saban
Alabama W
So much for those critics speaking of the 6-6 season in Bama. Few at LSU remember that UAB loss in his early career in the Bayou, and it appears that he might finally have the mind set in Tuscaloosa to dominate like he expects. Not to mention getting the phone call from Bowden this week on just how his team kicked the Tigers' ass. Bama is expected to be undefeated headed to Athens in late September, so no chance of Saban to move higher. But a 5-0 record with a victory over UGA, would move Saban to the top of the conference.

3 Les Miles
LSU W
Miles avoids pulling a Lloyd Carr, keeps his team (and fans) up with a game moved due to a hurricane, dominates a confident team with a Harvard QB, and yet falls to No. 3? This isn't as much to do with Les as to do with how great Bama looked under Saban against Clemson.

4 Mark Richt
Georgia W
Richt's team came out and dominated a lesser opponent at home. Good to see that UGA had some swagger and handed a big loss to an opponent that was foaming at the mouth to beat up on big Brother. With the Bama win (which appears to be dominating this post),, Richt will look even more impressive if he can get through the first half of the season unscathed - Central Michigan, at South Carolina, at Arizona State, Alabama. Whew.

5 Tommy Tuberville
Auburn W
Tommy's decision to go to the spread has already been ridiculed, as the Tigers garnered less than 100 yards passing* in its first outing. While Auburn's offense hasn't been exactly explosive since the 2005 season, the change to the spread was suppose to open up the Tigers. After one game, some Tigers are hunkering for the days of Gorgeous Borges. With Burns' play limited, Tommy needs to find a QB before the showdown with LSU on Sept. 20.

6 Steve Spurrier
South Carolina W
Written prior to Thursday night game: Spurrier tried to make a switch at QB. Was finally getting away from the Smelley O, but his QBs haven't exactly been dependable. Garcia was too much of a thug, even having Spurrier leave it to the S.C. administration (who somehow let him back into school and back on the team), and then Beecher, who according to Gamecock fans, has told many that he was given this position by the grace of God, found out that God must really like NC ST defensive backs. Now Smelley is back to the starter, and Spurrier's O is back to an amusement. Still he rises over the horrible coaching done by Fulmer in L.A and NC St playing it's gymnastics team at offense.

7 Phil Fulmer
Tennessee L
Fulmer drops a spot, and is barely holding this over Houston Nutt. Tennessee was suppose to have a breakout year, and apparently thought they had the game in the bag at halftime. UCLA's 3rd string QB had 4 interceptions, one returned for a TD to end the first half, and other than a blocked punt, UT was in control. Then the Vols gave up two TDs in the 2nd half only to lose the game in OT. This game should've been out-of-reach by halftime, but instead, UT drops the ball and loses respect for the SEC. Nice Job Phil.

8 Houston Nutt
Ole Miss W
I know that the days of DeAngelo Williams are long gone in the land of the Liberty Bowl, but Ole Miss has struggled with this Memphis opener for the past decade, but Nutt's team cruised to an easy victory, and scored more points than in the entire Oregeron era. While that might be a (small) exaggeration, I think that Ole Miss is poised to have a good year, and Nutt will lead the way.

9 Rich Brooks
Kentucky W
While Louisville doesn't have the raw talent of the 6-6 2007 team, their current QB is supposedly a potential NFL starter that put up zero points against Kentucky. The Wildcats hadn't won in Louisville for almost a decade, and now under Brooks, they have a two game winning streak. UK was suppose to struggle on offense, and while UL isn't near the competition of an SEC team, I was impressed by UK dominating it's opponent. Brooks won't move any higher than this unless he can get UK into another bowl and a big win (or two) over SEC teams.

10 Bobby Petrino
Arkansas W
Arkansas came out and won a game in the first day of a new era, which is better than can be said than in AnnArbor or College Station. Petrino won't rise in these rankings until I see him compete competitively each week.

11 Sly Croom
Mississippi State L
This wasn't just a hiccup against an inferior CUSA team; this was a major warning that MSU might have played far beyond themselves last year and are headed back to the poor times. Croom is a good coach and a great man, but his preseason ranking was for the SEC Coach of the Year season, and now with this 5-turnover loss in Ruston, Croom is going to find it difficult not to drop back to bottom of the SEC. A loss to Southeastern Lousiana on Saturday would send Croom to the back of the SEC bus.

12Bobby Johnson
Vanderbilt W
Written prior to Thursday night game: Vandy defeats Miami of Ohio. Bobby stays at No. 12. Win 4 games, you'll move up to 11; win 5 games you'll move up to 10. Win 6 games and get to a bowl game? I'll put him at 6. (well, probably not).

*Originally, I had 100 yards of offense; I meant to say 100 passing yards. Auburn had more than 400 yards of total offense against LaMonroe.

Sunday, August 31, 2008

SEC Coaching Board


The coaching rankings for the SEC. Each week, the rankings will be updated to reflect each coaches game and season-to-date performances.

Urban Meyer
Florida
Beginning with his time at Bowling Green, Meyer has been a winner everywhere, with an undefeated season in 2004 at Utah, and the 2006 National Championship at Florida. The only knock on him was that he had not stayed at a school long enough to see the effects of his recruiting; now in his fourth season at Florida and with top notch recruiting classes thus far, this appears to have been a needless concern. Now, the only concern is that Richt is going to change the course of the rivalry and emerge as the top contender of the SEC.

Les Miles
LSU
Les is more... More confusion, more bonehead plays and more wins in three seasons at LSU then Nick Saban. The most bizarre thing that happened last season wasn't that App St won in the Big House, or Stanford in the LA Coliseum, it was that Miles' bonehead calls actually lead him to the national title game, and that the month off gave his very talented team (that he has to thank Nick Saban for?) to get well enough to trounce Ohio St. Sure he couldn't have beaten UGA in the SEC Championship game, but he has gone 34-6 over three years. While that is sure to change, Miles has earned the number two position in a very stacked deck of amazing coaches. I look to him to fall to the middle of the pack by year's end.

Nick Saban
Alabama
Once anointed the new king of the SEC prior to his LSU departure, Saban resides this high only due to his time in the Bayou and his ability to get top-notch recruits. The 6-6 campaign means that Saban holds the No. 3 spot by a thread and is likely to be the quickest to fall, especially with Richt on his heels.

Mark Richt
Georgia
Richt's tenure at UGA has been nothing short of astounding. While there were initial growing pains during his early years, Richt has won 3 conference championships and has fallen short of a national title twice. Since 2002, UGA's averaged final ranking has been No. 9, and is the only team to be ranked in the final poll every year for those past six years, and finished No. 3 in 2002 and No. 2 in 2007.

Tommy Tuberville
Auburn
Tuberville's time has been amazing at Auburn, leading the Tigers out of the SEC West cellar and into a perennial SEC West power, not to mention getting them out of the shady Pat Dye/Terry Bowden recruiting scandals. While winning 50 games in the past 5 years with numerous victories over Top 10 teams, Tuberville's biggest knock is losing the game his team is suppose to win, outside the loaded 2004 team.

Phil Fulmer
Tennessee
It has been 10 years since Tennessee won a conference championship, and over that 10 years, UT had an amazing opportunity to take control of the SEC East, if not the SEC itself, only to flounder away the opportunities. His archnemis left Fulmer alone as the big gun in the East, only to see Richt raise UGA from a perennial No. 3 to the top dog of the conference. Fulmer's team has played in the championship game 3 times since 2001, but have found little success without Peyton or David Cutcliff.

Steve Spurrier
South Carolina
The King of the SEC in the '90's; the new Bear; the Ole Ball Coach returned to the SEC in 2005 and has only had marginal success with the Gamecocks. Receiving far less credit for success at his previous position than Saban has, Spurrier was close to a breakout season in 2007, taking USC to No. 6 before losing the final 5 games of the season. And while he has been able to defeat each of the big 3, it's the S.Carolina losing mentality that Spurrier has yet been able to change.

Houston Nutt
Ole Miss
For what he did at Arkansas, Nutt would be a top 2 coach in almost any other conference. In the SEC it puts him at numero ocho. He's coached two Razorback teams to SEC championship games, and after getting little love in 10 seasons in Fayetteville, finally decided to march off, to possibly a better position. The question is whether he can get away from his ultraconservative ground game and create a more balanced team in Oxford. My guess is that he's going to make the Rebels a very formidable team, and possibly begin to cherry-pick the talent in Texas and Louisiana. I wouldn't be surprised if Ole Miss became the No. 3 team in the West (ahead of LSU or Auburn), similar to a position it almost claimed in the mid-to-late 90's.

Sly Croom
Mississippi State
After a rocky start in his first few years, Croom took MSU to its first bowl game since 2000. Named the 2007 SEC Coach of the Year, Croom defeated Ole Miss, Auburn and No. 14 Kentucky, and holds a two game winning streak over Alabama. Like Tuberville, Croom has considerably cleaned up the image in Starkville (which is partly why he receives the nod over Petrino), but with the current coaching SEC line-up, Croom will have to continue to fight just to hold this spot.

Bobby Petrino
Arkansas
Yes, yes Petrino is god's gift to offense; everyone's been told how amazing he is, and how wonderful Louisville was when he was there... But was it really? He coached in the Big East with little other competition, and had the talent and schedule to make an annual run at the national title, but almost came up short. The win in 2005 over Miami might have been a signature win, but looking back, was it really that impressive. Not to mention that the guy is about as sleazy as you can get, and has the worst stench of any coach in football.

Rich Brooks
Kentucky
People say that Rich Brooks has had success wherever he's gone. I guess that's true, as long as success means mediocrity, and I guess it does in Oregon and Kentucky. Brooks' team has been ranked in the final AP Top 25 once in his 30+ year career. Once. In a conference like the SEC, being an average coach means that you're outside the Top 10.

Bobby Johnson
Vanderbilt
Bobby Johnson has kept Vanderbilt very competitive over the past few years, but that's always been Vandy - keep it close and perhaps find a way to win one out of 10. Johnson gets a lot of credit, especially with recent victories over UGA, Tenn and No. 6 S.Carolina, but with this success, he has yet to get Vandy that elusive sixth win. Also, it appears that it will be under Johnson's watch when Vandy finally slips under .500 all-time.